Your Briefing
On one Tuesday morning in September, the board received three pieces of bad news and set a two-week deadline.
What just happened
On a Tuesday morning in September, the board of Pine Ridge Regional Hospital received three blows in a row. CMS confirmed the hospital will lose $847,000 in Medicare reimbursements next year for excessive readmissions. That is the third straight year of penalties, and this year's is 40% higher than last year's. The state released its quality ratings and placed Pine Ridge in the bottom 15% statewide for infections, falls, and sepsis deaths, and the local paper ran the headline "Is Pine Ridge Regional Safe?". And the CFO projected a $3.2 million operating loss for a hospital already carrying $12 million in debt.
The board chair said out loud what the room was thinking: "We might actually have to close."
Your assignment
You are the newly hired VP of Strategy. The board has given CEO Dr. Sarah Chen two weeks to present a governance-driven turnaround plan. If they are not convinced it is feasible, they vote on closure.
Your job: pick one of the hospital's quality problems, use the hospital's own data to find its root cause, design an improvement, and make the case that the change is worth it.
How to use this case
Nothing here is submitted or graded. This is your space to investigate. Read the situation, dig through the quality and financial data, and interview the people who work here. Each of them can tell you a different piece of the story.
Take what you gather back to your assignment template to build your root-cause analysis and improvement plan.
The Hospital and How It Got Here
It is the only hospital for a county of 28,000 people, run by a board that had stopped paying attention.
A hospital that mattered
Pine Ridge opened in 1968, built with community donations and Hill-Burton federal funding. For decades it was a source of pride. It was where generations were born, where the high school football team got X-rays after Friday night games, and where elderly farmers got their diabetes care. Closure would not just remove a hospital. It would force the community's most vulnerable residents to drive an hour for basic care, and it would gut a major local employer.
Years of slow decline
- Patient volume falling 8% a year as residents drive to the regional medical center in Riverside City for anything beyond basic care.
- Revenue leans heavily on government payers: 58% Medicare, 23% Medicaid, only 15% commercial insurance.
- The state chose not to expand Medicaid, leaving 4,200 county residents uninsured.
- Specialty services cut over the past decade: no obstetrics since 2019, surgery reduced to emergency procedures only, specialty clinics gone.
What went wrong in the boardroom
When Dr. Chen arrived nine months ago, she inherited a mess, and she discovered a board that had been asleep at the wheel.
- No quality oversight. The board had not reviewed quality metrics in 18 months. When the quality director tried to present infection data, she was told "we don't have time for that level of detail." Meetings ran on parking-lot maintenance and routine purchases.
- No strategy. The last strategic plan was written in 2017 and is gathering dust. No serious discussion of declining volume, reimbursement shifts, or the Medicaid decision.
- Thin financial oversight. The board saw basic reports but never dug into trends. No one systematically tracked payer mix or service-line profitability.
- No accountability. The previous CEO served 19 years with minimal evaluation. Department heads had no quality or financial targets. When readmissions climbed, no one owned the fix.
- A demoralized medical staff. Physicians felt unsupported, with outdated equipment and thin staffing, and several began sending patients to Riverside City for procedures Pine Ridge could technically perform, because "I just don't trust our systems anymore."
Quality Dashboard
How Pine Ridge compares with the benchmark on each of the four problems. Longer red bars are worse.
| Quality problem | Pine Ridge | Benchmark / target | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| Surgical site infection rate | 3.2% | 1.7% (state average) | Nearly double the state average |
| Patient falls (per 1,000 patient-days) | 12.0 | 4.8 (state average) | 2.5 times the state average |
| Sepsis mortality | 34% | 22% (state average) | 12 points above average |
| 30-day all-cause readmissions | 19.7% | 15% (CMS penalty threshold) | Above the CMS penalty line |
Surgical Site Infections (SSI)
Nearly 2x benchmarkRoughly 1 in 31 surgical patients develops an infection, against a state rate closer to 1 in 59. Ask Dr. Ruiz or Diane Okafor what they see in the OR.
Patient Falls
2.5x benchmarkFalls per 1,000 patient-days. Pine Ridge patients fall 2.5 times as often as the state norm. Ask Pat Nguyen, the med-surg nurse manager.
Sepsis Mortality
+12 pointsMore than 1 in 3 sepsis patients dies at Pine Ridge, versus roughly 1 in 5 statewide. Ask Dr. Bright, the hospitalist.
30-Day Readmissions
Above CMS penalty lineAll-cause 30-day readmissions sit 4.7 points over the line where CMS penalties kick in, and that gap is the direct driver of the $847K penalty. Ask Rob Diaz in case management.
The Financials
A hospital caught in a vicious cycle, with about 90 days of cash left.
Why revenue is falling
- Volume loss from a damaged reputation and patients leaving for Riverside City.
- Rising Medicare penalties, both HRRP readmission penalties and value-based purchasing reductions.
- Payer mix shifting toward government programs that reimburse less.
- Two operating rooms running at just 23% capacity.
Why costs are rising
- Premium pay for temporary "travel" nurses filling staffing gaps.
- Expensive outside consultants brought in for compliance problems.
- Malpractice insurance climbing after adverse events.
- Aging infrastructure needing constant repair.
The payer mix
Because most patients are covered by government programs that pay less than commercial insurance, Pine Ridge earns relatively little per patient, and it cannot easily raise prices to escape the squeeze.
| Payer | Share of patients | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Medicare | 58% | Fixed government rates; source of the readmission penalties |
| Medicaid | 23% | Lowest reimbursement of the major payers |
| Commercial insurance | 15% | Best-paying, but the smallest slice |
| Uninsured / self-pay | ~4% | State declined Medicaid expansion; 4,200 residents uninsured |
Talk to the Staff
Pick someone to interview. Each person sees a different piece of the puzzle. Expand a question to hear how they answer.
👆 Select a staff member above to start an interview. The yellow notes under some answers flag details worth chasing down for your root-cause analysis.
The Board's Decision
Three options are on the table. Your turnaround case has to be strong enough to beat the other two.
Option 1: Close the hospital
Sell the facility, lay off all staff, and end local acute care.The case for
- Stops the financial bleeding immediately.
- Avoids taking on more debt against a shrinking base.
- Some board members see decline as inevitable, and think delay only deepens the hole.
The case against
- 28,000 people lose local acute care, and the nearest hospital is 62 miles away.
- 312 jobs gone, in the county's 2nd-largest employer.
- The most vulnerable residents are hit hardest.
Option 2: Convert to a Rural Emergency Hospital (REH)
Downsize to emergency and outpatient services only, under the Medicare REH designation.The case for
- Preserves 24/7 emergency access for the community.
- The REH designation adds a monthly facility payment plus an outpatient add-on.
- A leaner cost structure without inpatient units.
The case against
- Eliminates all inpatient care, so admissions must be transferred out.
- Loses inpatient revenue and may read to the community as a downgrade.
- Eligibility rules apply, and the shift is hard to reverse.
Option 3: Attempt a turnaround
Reform governance, fix quality, and rebuild revenue. This is the plan you have been asked to build.The case for
- Preserves the full-service hospital and the jobs.
- Targets the root problems driving penalties and lost volume.
- Reversing readmissions and reputation could restore both trust and revenue.
The case against
- The hardest path, requiring real board engagement and capital the hospital lacks.
- The 90-day cash cushion leaves little room for error.
- Execution risk is high, and it may still fail.